×

Ayushman Bharat :A Critical Appraisal

Ayushman Bharat :A Critical Appraisal
Ayushman Bharat :A Critical Appraisal
Written By- Dr Sanjay Gupta

Ayushman bharat is a scheme which seems very altruistic ostensibly but has not proven to be cost effective . The people who should really be under ambit of the scheme are out. Good number of beneficiaries are actually above poverty line who evade exit from the scheme due to obvious political reasons. 80%of sweepers working in my hospital donot have AB as their papers are not proper. People who come in Bolero and scorpios flaunt AB cards. They are the vote feeders for the parties. AB for govt institutions is like अंधा बांटे रेवड़ी फिर आपन को देय । what is the need for them? They are already govt funded. The question is why private practice, small and medium hospitals flourished in last 20 years? 

 Because-

1. The people became quality conscious? 

2.The services in govt hospitals continued to deteriorate? 

3.The financial status of public in general improved as their purchasing capacity went up? Those who used hand waved fans in their houses have now installed ACs.

It was mostly middle class which switched from govt to private. This the class which is inherently thrifty and saving saavy in nature.This class joined the rat race of show off but they spend and lament about it. The private sector provided better services to this class but with a cost, hence it got soon maligned as greedy, and doctors as fleecers. The people didn't want to go to govt hospitals, but had to spend in private with a heavy heart. People selected their private service providers as their grocery shops according to their pockets but always looked upon them with suspicion. Its seemed a forced conversion though. People take pride in purchasing costly vehicles (one of the reasons Nano car failed), they take pride in arranging fat, hefty wedding ceremonies , but any expenditure on health issues comes as a great curse. OK this is general mentality I am not blaming but simply alluding to.

Now about AB scheme -

Its a unilateral scheme which seems to have been designed by non clinicians, without including the stake holders. Most of the HBPs are poorly designed and poorly priced too.

Package treatment always leads to price cutting and delivery of poor quality of service. It affects the treatment decisions and fetters the clinical decisions to limit within the package cost, which ultimately reflects on the treatment outcomes. There are a number of examples but just take haemodialysis here. The initiation of dialysis requires vascular access. The whole thing on cost to cost basis needs at least 5 to6 thousand rupees but you get 1485 /_without 33%income tax deduction. Will a hospital spend from its own pocket? Costly antibiotics meropenem and albumin are added in new packages recently but surprizingly for the treatment of respiratory failure and sepsis only.not for Nephrotic syndrome and chronic liver disease where they are needed the most .Blood transfusions are not attached to dialysis packages !!! Surprising There is so much incongruence and disparity in packages. On top of it claim rejection after initial CPD approval is a big shock to private player. They feel cheated. Poor packages and unpredictable claim disbursal leads to corruption at all levels and it is decaying the whole scheme. The payments are also delayed even for months to years. So cost cutting , poorly designed packages, unpredictable, non transparent claim approval and rejection processes added to delayed payments is a big deterrent for quality private hospitals to adopt this scheme. The musroomed small nursing homes run by politicians, builders, contractors, property dealers are happy dealing in AB pts as they have a knack of recovering money from govt through their devious corrupt ways. The honest hospitals mostly run by qualified doctors always languish. The scheme has proven as panacea for dying private medical colleges, who required to treat pts free, but now getting money as reward from AB. 

I can write a whole book on scheme but would limit myself here. On the flipside there are a number of good things delivered through the scheme too. But however altruistic the scheme be, from the point of view of the planners and politicians, it certainly needs a reappraisal, and a revamp. The stakeholders, field specialists, private docs should also be a party in designing the rates, patterns and structure of health benefit packages.

(Dr Sanjay Gupta is a senior Nephrologist from Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, He is Hon. Secretary of Madhya Pradesh Private Hospitals & Nursing Homes Association,Views are personal)

 





The Pacemakers' website features articles expressing individual authors' opinions, with the owner neither endorsing nor taking responsibility for the content. The views presented are solely those of the authors, and readers are advised to use discretion, as the website is not liable for any consequences. Geared towards medical professionals, the site emphasizes that its content does not replace healthcare advice, and users must adhere to the terms of use and privacy policy. © Limbic System Healthcare Solutions LLP



Recent comments

Latest Comments section by users


avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Nice article boss We all need to strongly unite and generate a voice against this points and put our position and sentiments towards this scheme Government is busy distributing free unnecessary schemes just for making voter happy and are borrowing large sums of money to again announce new schemes every now and then And we are putting our hard earned money in hope that payment which are absolutely low, would be returned to us Giving AY facility is becoming a burden to us and many institutions are running low of funds and are forced to provide low grade facilities You are correct sir We can talk about this on and on




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Very nice write up sir 🙏




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Dr Yogendra Kothari Physician Anuyog Hospital and research center Mandsaur MP




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Dr Yogendra Kothari Physician Anuyog Hospital and research center Mandsaur MP




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Very true, govt should take some remedial action in this scheme.




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Nice article sir everyone is facing difficulties due to lacking of ground realities




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

AB is very helpful for poor only when it is implemented in right direction. Scrutinising of AB cards most needed. AB should be applied for all medical problems if patient get admitted for more than 3 days. (Dr KL Rathore)




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Very aptly described the pitfalls of scheme and misutization of funds meant to benefit people with low income sources




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Excellent analysis brother




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Good analysis




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Good analysis and nicely written blog but not fully true . Very generic statements and based on individual perceptions , assumptions and presumptions which disconnected from ground realities.




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Seems you are well in the thick of scheme. You are well connected, give your detailed comments and suggestions to the state nodal agencies with an action plan to implement based on your suggestions, if you are really serious of making some change




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Dear sir , Mr SPS Baghel , the then MOS for MOHFw had been to bhopal once , he was incharge of this scheme . He brought one young IAS officer from NHA along with him . All related nursing home owners , medical college owners were there . It was expressed by all means that we want to serve public through this scheme , but as we are private players we also need money to continue and sustain . The pros and cons of the scheme were discussed at large . Notes and minutes of meeting were prepared but we are still waiting for the decisions to take place /implement on grounds . We were happy after the meeting ended . But to our chagrin , it still proved futile to no avail




avatar
Guest

Sep 16, 2024

Dr Sanjay Gupta MD DM DNB




avatar
Guest

Sep 17, 2024

Practical observations - even if a bit critically skewed, yet, to the point. There may be positive advantages ( short-term) to some --- but for the health professionals, and the general public, in the long run --- only the upcoming timelines may be a better judge. Regards. 💕✍🏼🧞‍♀️👩🏻‍⚕️🕊🇮🇳




avatar
Guest

Sep 20, 2024

अत्युत्तम्




avatar
Guest

Oct 06, 2024

Purchase Ativan Online. Acquire Ativan, alternatively recognized as Lorazepam, through online channels. This prescription medication is frequently prescribed to address anxiety disorders, insomnia, and specific seizure disorders. https://www.cureus.com/users/676621-doctor-morgan Order Ativan Online Overnight [url=https://www.cureus.com/users/676621-doctor-morgan]Order Ativan Online Overnight[/url] [url=https://medee.mn/single/169551]Fenterdren Reviews[/url] be5_293




avatar
Guest

Oct 07, 2024

Purchase Ativan Online. Acquire Ativan, alternatively recognized as Lorazepam, through online channels. This prescription medication is frequently prescribed to address anxiety disorders, insomnia, and specific seizure disorders. https://www.cureus.com/users/676621-doctor-morgan Order Ativan Online Overnight [url=https://www.cureus.com/users/676621-doctor-morgan]Order Ativan Online Overnight[/url] [url=http://www2s.biglobe.ne.jp/%7Epine/bbs/minibbs.cgi?]Papilas 37.5 Can It Be Cut In Half[/url] 2cef19f




avatar
Guest

Oct 08, 2024

- The Pacemakers affxjtplvoh ffxjtplvoh http://www.gucbskd2t874uhg873wln8756p7z8010s.org/ [url=http://www.gucbskd2t874uhg873wln8756p7z8010s.org/]uffxjtplvoh[/url]