Understanding Medical Negligence- Civil vs Criminal
The Supreme Court, in its landmark judgment in the case of Jacob Mathew vs. State of Punjab, has extensively discussed this issue. The court not only understood the challenges faced by doctors as professionals but also beautifully explained the difference between civil and criminal negligence. However, it is unfortunate that even after twenty years of this historic judgment, doctors are still facing the same ordeal as Dr. Jacob Mathew faced in that case. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has repeatedly stated that criminal FIRs should not be registered against doctors without the opinion of medical experts, but this is not being followed. Either the police do not seek the opinion of the medical board or the medical board fails to give an opinion in line with the spirit of the Jacob Mathew case. Whatever the reason, the concerned doctor has to go through severe mental, economic, social, and professional harassment.
Healing the Healers: Addressing the Struggles of Medical Students and Resident Doctors
The pursuit of a medical career is often considered a noble and prestigious journey, one that requires immense dedication, intelligence, and resilience. Yet, behind the facade of white coats and healing hands lies a complex and deeply troubling reality faced by medical students and resident doctors. The profession, demanding as it is, comes with profound challenges that place an unbearable strain on the mental, emotional, and physical well-being of those on the frontlines. The issues they encounter are not simply occasional hurdles but systemic problems that demand urgent attention and reform.
A Cry for True Freedom: The Unheard Voices of Healers
There can be no celebration, no joy, only the silent, steadfast resolve to fight for a future where freedom is not just a word but a lived reality for every doctor, every healthcare worker, and every citizen of this land.The medical community, the healers of this nation, should only consider celebrating Independence Day when this noble profession is finally liberated from the shackles of violence,
No One Rigged NEET 2024
Despite the avalanche of facts and evidence, the claim that the NEET exam paper was leaked on a large scale remains unsubstantiated. The word "integrity" should embody an untouchable sanctity, yet in the context of NEET 2024, its essence appears to have been diluted. In the past, any breach in the paper's chain of custody was enough to declare a compromise in exam integrity. Now, a localized leak does not seem to tarnish the sanctity of the examination. In this digital era, the distinction between local and global leaks appears almost ludicrous.
Chances of re exam have increased, students deserve better representation in Court
The NEET case now appears to be reaching a decisive stage. During the hearing, the Supreme Court made stern remarks, stating that a paper leak on social media would spread like wildfire. The court also mentioned that if there is a significant gap between the printing of the paper and the exam, the likelihood of a widespread leak is still high.The court also made serious comments onThe rank inflation, noting that the kind of inflation being seen is unusual and should be investigated. When the next hearing takes place on July 11, the following points should be presented before the court.
NEET Tragedy - Dilemma between Injustice and Inconvenience
The affidavit submitted by the government to the Supreme Court acknowledges that the paper was leaked in limited areas, while until a few days ago, the government was completely denying this. The Union Education Minister had explicitly denied any paper leak. The NTA also did not acknowledge any paper leak in its press releases, even though evidence started emerging on the day of the exam itself, on May 5.
When Will the Children Suffering from the NEET Tragedy Get Relief ?
Thousands of dreams are broken. Parents, who took loans for their children's education, hoping they would become doctors and repay the debts, are in deep despair. Future NEET aspirants are also in mental turmoil, unsure of their goals. Even if they score 670, will they get a government college seat? Their lives seem to have come to a standstill, unable to see the dawn of this dark night. The system talks about future measures but ignores the innocent children trapped in the NEET tragedy, their tender minds bleeding. No one seems to be there to gather their shattered dreams. Many children might stop dreaming of becoming doctors, and even if they do, having witnessed this tragedy closely, they might prefer to migrate to another country. Perhaps this country doesn't need their talent.
Students on Streets and Shameless System
Students across the nation have taken to the streets to protest against the glaring irregularities in NEET 2024. There is widespread anger among students and their parents, who believe that NTA's negligence and corruption led to a significant paper leak, resulting in a cut-off increase by 50-60 marks. NTA exacerbated the situation by awarding grace marks arbitrarily. In a public notice issued on June 6, NTA admitted to granting grace marks to over 1,500 students.
Understanding Medical Accidents through the Swiss Cheese Theory
Medical negligence is a complex issue that cannot be easily adjudicated in consumer courts. Even among medical experts, opinions can diverge significantly on the same case with the same evidence. This complexity is why the medical community seeks exemptions from trials in consumer commissions—not to evade accountability but to ensure that cases of alleged medical negligence are evaluated with the nuance and expertise they require.
A comparative analysis of services rendered by Doctors and Advocates to their clients in relation to Consumer Protection Act
In the recent case related to inclusion/exclusion of legal services within the purview of the CP Act it was observed by the Bench that the service rendered by the Advocates practicing Legal Profession could be said to be the Service under “a contract of personal service,” so as to exclude it from the definition of “Service” contemplated under the Act. Medical community feels that when same arguments are applied to doctors as medical professional their services may also be considered under the category of "Contract of personal service"
Government Fails in Medical Entrance Exams
भारत के उच्च शिक्षण संस्थानों में प्रवेश सबंधी परीक्षाओं में खुद सरकार की असफलता सामने आ चुकी है। मेडिकल प्रवेश परीक्षा नीट 2024 की जांच सीबीआई को सौप दी गई है। आशा है कि इस प्रकरण दोषियों को सजा मिलेगी। इस परीक्षा के संदर्भ में काफी खुलासे हो चुके हैं। किसी जांच एजेंसी के लिए इस नतीजे पर पहुंचना मुश्किल नहीं कि पेपर लीक हुआ और परीक्षा की शुचिता भंग हुई।
